(Beware: this post is about Serious Business and somewhat political. You’ve been warned.)
Last night I was chatting with my good friend Z about same-sex marriage. Z is one of my “gay friends”, if you want to call it that. Our conversation got me thinking about my own upcoming nuptials and how I could best recognize the fact that we, as two people entering into a privileged heterosexual marriage, are able to take this very important step in our relationship while some of our closest friends and family cannot do the same.
Between Jason and I, we have a lot of friends who are gay. Many of those friends will be guests at our wedding. I simply cannot in good faith stand in front of those people and say my vows and parade my so-called privilege in front of them, when inside I am asking myself, “What ‘privilege’? What have I done that is more ‘worthy’ of marriage than them?” So the question then became: how can we recognize this disgusting disparity in equality, without causing undue drama and tension on a day that is supposed to be filled with happiness? I want to be respectful to those with different opinions, but I also want to make it known that Jason and I respectfully disagree.
There have been many, many recent blog posts, articles, and forum threads about different ways that heterosexual couples are recognizing this issue within their ceremonies and/or receptions. Offbeat Bride has a really great post listing 10 ways to show your support for marriage equality at your wedding.
One very simple option is to only use vendors who are same-sex friendly. This can be difficult if you’re on a budget or don’t have the time to hunt around for friendly vendors, but for those who are able to, this is a very powerful way to make your voice heard. There is no more powerful motivator than the dollar. You can find a great directory of same-sex friendly wedding vendors on So You’re Engayged.
Another popular option is the White Knot for Marriage Equality campaign. Many brides are placing a basket of white knot pins next to their program basket, or on the guestbook table at the reception, with a sign inciting those who support same-sex marriage to take a knot and wear it proudly, and providing more information about the campaign and ways to help.

{via OffBeat Bride}
This is a fine idea, however, I don’t think it’s quite enough — those little knots will be worn by those who support equal marriage rights, and ignored by those who don’t. It doesn’t start any kind of thought process, discussion, dialogue, anything — something also known as “slacktivism“. I want something that, while still tasteful and tactful, is something that no one can ignore. I don’t pretend to think that I can change people’s minds with one short mention of the issue in our wedding ceremony, but I do want it to be clear that this is an issue that we supporters will not be quiet about until full, equal rights are recognized for everyone.
So I started to think of something that would literally speak to everyone — a reading during the ceremony. The most popular such reading is the Goodrich vs. Department of Health ruling. I really like this one because of its subtle-yet-powerful tone. It is not an in-your-face blow to those who hold different opinions on the matter, but it does come from an angle of plain, pure logic, which is hard (if not impossible) to argue with. The actual ruling is rather long (you can read it here), but there are a few popular condensed versions floating around that are better used for wedding readings. One version I’ve found to touch on the most important points is this one (from About.com):
“Marriage is a vital social institution. The exclusive commitment of two individuals to each other nurtures love and mutual support; it brings stability to our society. For those who choose to marry, and for their children, marriage provides an abundance of legal, financial, and social benefits. In return it imposes weighty legal, financial, and social obligations….Without question, civil marriage enhances the ‘welfare of the community.’ It is a ‘social institution of the highest importance.’
Marriage also bestows enormous private and social advantages on those who choose to marry. Civil marriage is at once a deeply personal commitment to another human being and a highly public celebration of the ideals of mutuality, companionship, intimacy, fidelity, and family…. Because it fulfills yearnings for security, safe haven, and connection that express our common humanity, civil marriage is an esteemed institution, and the decision whether and whom to marry is among life’s momentous acts of self-definition.”
This reading is very meaningful and powerful to me, and it is subtle enough that it won’t make anyone truly uncomfortable to be at our ceremony. In a word, it is perfect for what we are looking for.
Along the same vein, one option that I haven’t seen much of elsewhere but that I also really like is to read Aristophanes’ speech from Plato’s Symposium. In his speech, Aristophanes tells the story of why soul mates exist. He says that human beings were originally four-armed, four-legged, two-faced beings — some two women, some two men, and some half man and half women — but that Zeus, fearing the power of these humans, split them all in two, so as to make them less powerful. These half-complete humans then spent their entire lives searching for their “other half” (and now you know where that phrase came from! Isn’t philosophy cool?!), and when they found them again, they spent the rest of their lives never leaving the other’s side.
I like this story because it not only is a very powerful description of love in general, but it is a subtle nod to the fact that same-sex relationships are just as “valid” in origin as heterosexual ones. Of course, again, this is a rather long story in its full form, and certain translations are more…wordy than others (you can read one here), but I think that if I searched enough I could find a good, condensed translation that could be used as a ceremony reading. This one is also especially fitting for us because I am a philosophy geek, and Jason and I can both appreciate a beautifully-worded story — which this story certainly is.
With what little specific thought we’ve given the ceremony so far, we know that including a nod to marriage equality is important to us. As we flesh out our ceremony more we will decide which reading we like better, and who we want to deliver the reading.
Are you making any statements about marriage equality at your wedding? What are you doing?